Five Horses Tavern stands as a cornerstone of the modern pub scene in the Greater Boston area, blending an approachable neighborhood vibe with a sophisticated bar program. With two primary locations in Boston’s historic South End and Somerville’s vibrant Davis Square, this establishment has built its reputation on a massive selection of rotating craft beers, locally sourced comfort food, and an inclusive menu that caters to diverse dietary needs.

The tavern operates as a dual-natured venue: a reliable spot for a casual weekday dinner and a high-energy destination for a celebrated weekend brunch. Whether searching for a rare New England IPA or a gluten-free version of a classic American burger, the tavern provides a curated experience that bridges the gap between a traditional dive bar and a fine-dining gastropub.

The Two Locations: South End vs. Davis Square

Understanding Five Horses Tavern requires recognizing the distinct personalities of its two locations. While they share a core menu and philosophy, the physical spaces and neighborhood dynamics offer different experiences for diners.

South End: Historic Charm and Expansive Patios

Located at 535 Columbus Avenue, the South End location is embedded in one of Boston’s most architecturally significant neighborhoods. The aesthetic here leans into the historic surroundings, featuring exposed brick walls and an atmosphere that feels both cozy and upscale.

One of the primary draws of the South End branch is its outdoor seating. Boasting one of the largest patios in the neighborhood, it serves as a premier destination for people-watching along Columbus Avenue during the warmer months. The proximity to Back Bay Station, the Prudential Center, and Northeastern University makes it a strategic meeting point for professionals, students, and tourists alike. The bar program here is slightly more focused on draft beer variety, typically offering 40 rotating taps to satisfy the most discerning enthusiasts.

Davis Square: The Whiskey Enthusiast’s Den

The Somerville location at 400 Highland Avenue sits in the heart of Davis Square, a cultural hub known for its independent theaters, proximity to Tufts University, and creative energy. This location is characterized by its high-ceilinged, industrial-meets-rustic interior and its deep connection to the local community.

While the South End is known for its patio, the Davis Square location is the crown jewel for spirits lovers. It houses an impressive collection of over 150 bourbons and whiskies sourced from across the globe. It serves as a post-show favorite for those attending the Somerville Theatre or a convenient stop for commuters utilizing the Red Line at Davis Square Station. The atmosphere here is often slightly more high-energy, reflecting the youthful and academic demographic of Somerville.

A Philosophy of Modern American Comfort Food

At its core, the kitchen at Five Horses Tavern is driven by the mission to redefine "comfort food." Instead of heavy, greasy pub fare, the menu emphasizes locally sourced ingredients and global culinary influences, resulting in dishes that are both familiar and innovative.

Inclusivity and Dietary Flexibility

A standout feature of the Five Horses menu is its commitment to inclusivity. In an era where dietary restrictions are common, the tavern provides extensive options for vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diners without sacrificing flavor. Almost every section of the menu—from starters to main entrees—features items labeled with a dietary key (GF, V, VG). For instance, the tavern’s ability to substitute a veggie patty in their signature burgers or provide gluten-free bread options ensures that groups with varying needs can dine together without compromise.

Signature Starters and Shared Plates

Dining at the tavern often begins with shared plates that set the tone for the meal. The Patatas Bravas are a fan favorite, featuring roasted potatoes seasoned with lime and chili, topped with cotija cheese and a signature chipotle aioli. This dish represents the kitchen’s penchant for adding a spicy, modern twist to traditional staples.

For those seeking classic pub flavors, the Haus Made Pretzel is a massive, salt-dusted offering served with warm beer cheese and spicy mustard. The Tavern Nachos take the sharing experience to the next level, utilizing a "dirty cheese sauce," refried black beans, pico de gallo, and cilantro-lime crema. The ability to add carnitas, chicken, or chili allows diners to customize the intensity of the dish.

Deep Dive into the Main Menu

The main courses at Five Horses Tavern range from hearty traditional pies to light, nutrient-dense bowls, ensuring there is a choice for every appetite.

The Tavern Burger and Sandwiches

The Tavern Burger is the centerpiece of the sandwich menu. It utilizes grass-fed beef topped with crispy onion strings, dirty cheese sauce, pickled cucumbers, and tomato preserves. The inclusion of kewpie mayo adds a creamy, umami-rich finish that differentiates it from standard tavern burgers.

Other notable mentions include the Chicken Sammy, which offers a choice between a sweet hot honey glaze or a garlic parmesan sauce. The Turkey Rachel—a variation of the Reuben—provides a lighter alternative with applewood smoked bacon and sliced turkey on toasted bread. Each sandwich comes with a variety of side options, ranging from classic tater tots and coleslaw to more unique choices like cucumber dill salad or cheddar jalapeno mashed potatoes.

Entrees: From Shepherd’s Pie to Tuna Poke

The entree selection highlights the tavern's versatility. The Shepherd’s Pie is a nod to traditional pub roots, combining ground beef and lamb with mixed vegetables, topped with a rich house mash and parmesan cheese. On the opposite end of the spectrum, the Tuna Poke Bowl caters to the modern, health-conscious diner, featuring white rice, ahi tuna, soy-ginger dressing, avocado, and seaweed salad.

Vegetarians often gravitate toward the Irish Curry, a robust dish filled with broccoli, bok choy, zucchini, and mushrooms in a savory brown curry sauce served over white rice. This global influence is a recurring theme, seen again in the Power Bowl, which uses a peanut sauce and farro base to create a satisfying, plant-based meal.

The Beer and Spirits Program

For many, the primary reason to visit Five Horses Tavern is the beverage list. The tavern doesn't just serve beer; it curates an evolving library of international and local brews.

The Rotating Draft System

Both locations pride themselves on a "rotating" tap system. This means that the beer list is rarely static. On any given day, a visitor might find a rare double IPA from a Vermont microbrewery alongside a crisp pilsner from Germany or a local stout from a Somerville-based nanobrewery. With 36 to 40 drafts and an additional 60 to 120 bottles depending on the location, the tavern is a destination for "ticker" culture—beer enthusiasts who enjoy trying as many unique brews as possible.

The Whiskey Collection in Davis Square

While the beer is the headline, the whiskey program in Davis Square deserves its own spotlight. With over 150 varieties, the bar staff is well-versed in the nuances of Kentucky bourbons, peated Islay scotches, and smooth Irish whiskies. Flights are often available, allowing guests to compare different mash bills or aging processes. This makes the tavern a sophisticated alternative to the more student-centric bars in the Somerville area.

The Weekend Brunch Experience

Saturday and Sunday mornings transform Five Horses Tavern into a bustling brunch hub. The brunch menu is an eclectic mix of sweet treats and savory cures for the previous night’s festivities.

Sweet and Savory Highlights

The Donut Holes, served with apple-cinonmon and a chocolate sugar glaze, are a common table-starter. For a more substantial meal, the Fried Chicken and Waffles (often featuring a bacon-cheddar-chive waffle and maple-chili syrup) offers a perfect balance of textures and flavors.

Savory seekers often choose the Old Dirty Benny (O.D.B.), a decadent take on Eggs Benedict using carnitas pulled pork and a house-made biscuit instead of an English muffin. The Pork Hash, featuring braised pork and roasted sweet and Yukon potatoes, is another hearty option that highlights the kitchen's skill with slow-cooked meats.

Brunch Cocktails

No tavern brunch is complete without a beverage. Beyond the standard mimosa, Five Horses offers a range of brunch cocktails, including signature Bloody Marys and creative espresso martinis. The Spicy Guava Margarita and the Thyme Sour are popular choices for those looking for something refreshing yet complex to accompany their eggs.

Practical Information: Logistics and Reservations

Navigating the dining scene in Boston and Somerville requires a bit of planning, particularly regarding transportation and timing.

Parking and Transportation

  • Davis Square: Parking in Somerville is notoriously difficult. The Davis Square location is best reached via the MBTA Red Line. However, for those driving, several metered lots exist. The Rite Aid lot (Highland Avenue) is the closest, though it fills up quickly. Other options include the Grove Street lots and the Day Street lot. It is important to note that meters are enforced Monday through Saturday until 8:00 PM.
  • South End: The South End location is a short walk from the Back Bay Station (Orange Line and Commuter Rail). Street parking is available on Columbus Avenue and surrounding side streets, but it is often limited to residents or heavily contested. Using public transit or ride-sharing apps is highly recommended for this location.

Reservations and Large Groups

Five Horses Tavern is a "neighborhood gem" that can get exceptionally busy during peak hours (Friday and Saturday nights, and Sunday brunch). While they welcome walk-ins, reservations are highly recommended and can be made via platforms like OpenTable.

The tavern is also one of the few venues in these neighborhoods that can comfortably accommodate large groups. For parties of 15 or more, the tavern typically requires direct contact via email or phone to ensure proper staffing and seating arrangements. This makes it a popular choice for graduation celebrations, birthday parties, and corporate happy hours.

Payment Methods

The tavern is modern in its operations, accepting all major credit cards. Notably, the Davis Square location accepts Jumbo Cash, a specialized payment system for Tufts University students, further cementing its role as a campus-adjacent staple.

Summary of the Five Horses Experience

Five Horses Tavern successfully balances the warmth of a neighborhood pub with the culinary ambition of a modern restaurant. By focusing on three pillars—extensive craft beer selection, inclusive comfort food, and vibrant neighborhood locations—it has carved out a unique space in the competitive Boston dining landscape. Whether you are a beer connoisseur looking for the latest draft release, a vegan seeking a high-quality meal, or a local resident looking for a reliable brunch spot, the tavern offers a consistent and high-quality experience.

FAQ

Does Five Horses Tavern have outdoor seating? Yes, both locations offer outdoor patio dining. The South End location is particularly famous for having one of the largest patios in the neighborhood, perfect for summer dining.

Are there vegetarian and vegan options at Five Horses Tavern? Absolutely. The menu is designed with dietary inclusivity in mind. Items like the Irish Curry, Power Bowl, and various salads are either naturally vegan/vegetarian or can be modified. They also offer veggie patties for their burgers.

Which location is better for whiskey lovers? While both have excellent bars, the Davis Square (Somerville) location is specifically known for its collection of over 150 bourbons and whiskies.

Is Five Horses Tavern kid-friendly? Yes, the tavern is a casual environment suitable for families, especially during lunch and early dinner hours. However, it transitions into a more adult-centric bar atmosphere late at night.

Do I need a reservation for brunch? Brunch is one of their most popular times. While walk-ins are welcome, there is often a significant wait on Sunday mornings. Booking a table in advance is strongly advised.

What are the closest T stops to the taverns? For the South End location, use the Orange Line (Back Bay Station) or the Green Line (Prudential). For the Davis Square location, the Red Line (Davis Square Station) is just a few minutes' walk away.

Does the menu change frequently? The core menu remains relatively stable, but the draft beer list changes daily as kegs are kicked and replaced with new selections. They also offer rotating seasonal soups and specials.

Is there a dress code? The dress code is casual. You will see people in everything from gym clothes to business casual attire.

Can I host a private event there? Yes, the tavern is equipped to handle large groups and private events. It is best to contact their events coordinator through the information provided on their official website.

Does the Davis Square location really accept Jumbo Cash? Yes, as a partner to the Tufts University community, the Davis Square location accepts Jumbo Cash as a valid form of payment.