If you are looking for the official menu and latest prices for The Pizza Heist, specifically the popular location in Lancaster, New York, you have come to the right place. This neighborhood favorite at 231 Aurora Street has built a reputation for serving a unique blend of Italian-American comfort food that goes far beyond standard cheese and pepperoni slices.

The Pizza Heist is famous for its "Stinger" items and creative specialty pies that challenge the traditional pizza norms. Whether you are planning a family dinner, looking for a Monday night special, or craving a late-night snack like funnel cake fries, this guide covers every corner of their extensive menu.

The Signature Experience: What Makes Their Pizza Unique

Before diving into the full price list, it is essential to understand the "Experience" at The Pizza Heist. In our local taste tests, two items consistently stand out as the pillars of their menu: the Stinger Pizza and the Rodeo Pizza.

The Stinger Pizza is a quintessential Western New York creation. It features a generous portion of steak and chopped chicken fingers (shaken in your choice of sauce) covered in a thick layer of melted mozzarella. What sets their version apart is the addition of fresh lettuce and tomato after baking, providing a cool, crisp contrast to the heavy, savory meats. The steak is tender, and when combined with the heat of medium-sauced chicken fingers, it creates a flavor profile that is both aggressive and satisfying.

The Rodeo Pizza is for those who enjoy a smoky, barbecue-forward profile. It uses a BBQ red sauce base instead of traditional marinara, topped with ground beef and blended cheeses. The real "heist" here is the addition of crispy onion rings on top, which add a structural crunch and a sweet, fried flavor that pairs perfectly with the beef.

Specialty Pizzas Menu and Pricing

The Pizza Heist offers over 16 different pizza options. They provide four main sizes: Personal, Small (12"), Large (16"), and Sheet (for large parties).

Gourmet Selections

  • Veggie Pizza: A loaded option with mushrooms, onions, your choice of peppers and olives, and a sprinkle of parmesan.
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99
  • White Pizza: A garlic-lover's dream brushed with house oil, covered with fresh tomato, onions, mozzarella, and heavy seasonings.
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99
  • Taco Pizza: A fusion of Mexican and Italian flavors. You can choose from taco meat, steak, or chicken. It is topped with black olives, tomatoes, blended cheeses, and fresh lettuce.
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99
  • Chicken Finger Pizza: You can choose between a red sauce or a blue cheese base. The fingers can be sauced (Hot, Medium, Mild, or BBQ).
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99
  • Steak Pizza: Brushed with house oil and topped with chopped steak, onions, and your choice of peppers.
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99
  • In The Grass Pizza: A classic combination of either chicken or steak mixed with fresh garlic and spinach, covered with blended cheeses.
    • Small: $17.99 | Large: $26.99 | Sheet: $39.99

Premium/Meat-Heavy Options

  • Carnivore Pizza: A massive mix of steak, sausage, and chicken with sautéed onions and peppers.
    • Small: $20.99 | Large: $37.99 | Sheet: $59.99
  • Stinger Pizza: The local legend featuring steak and chicken fingers.
    • Small: $20.99 | Large: $37.99 | Sheet: $59.99
  • Rodeo Pizza: BBQ base with ground beef and onion rings.
    • Small: $20.99 | Large: $37.99 | Sheet: $59.99

Build Your Own Pizza

For those who prefer to keep it simple or create their own masterpiece, The Pizza Heist offers a "Build Your Own" service. They offer regular or thin crust options.

Size Cheese Only Additional Topping Specialty Topping
Personal $5.99 $1.25 $2.25
Small $10.99 $2.25 $3.25
Large $14.99 $3.25 $5.25
Sheet $26.99 $6.00 $10.00

Standard Toppings Include: Pepperoni, mushrooms, green olives, black olives, ham, bacon, sausage, meatballs, onions, green peppers, hot peppers, and banana peppers. Special Crusts: A cauliflower crust is available for an additional $3.00 for health-conscious diners.

Chicken Wings and Fingers

In Lancaster, you cannot have a pizza shop without excellent wings. The Pizza Heist serves their wings with blue cheese and celery (and carrots upon request).

Wing Sauces and Styles

Sauce options include: Hot, Medium, Mild, Garlic Parm, BBQ, Char-broiled, Honey Mustard, Hot BBQ, and Extra Hot.

  • Regular Wings:
    • 10 Pieces: $14.99
    • 20 Pieces: $26.99
    • 30 Pieces: $38.99
    • 50 Pieces: $59.99
  • Boneless Wings:
    • 10 Pieces: $11.99
    • 20 Pieces: $19.99
    • 30 Pieces: $27.99
    • 50 Pieces: $45.99
  • Chicken Fingers: Served with fries, blue cheese, and celery.
    • 5 Pieces: $16.99
    • 10 Pieces: $28.99
    • 25 Pieces: $55.99

Subs, Wraps, and Tacos

A standout feature of the sub menu is the use of Costanzo’s rolls, a local Buffalo staple known for their perfect balance of a crusty exterior and soft, airy interior.

Cold Subs

All cold subs include lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and your choice of mayo or seasoned oil.

  • Ham, Turkey, or Salami: Mini $7.99 | Whole $10.99
  • Assorted (Ham, Salami, Capicola): Mini $8.99 | Whole $11.99
  • Turkey Club: Mini $9.99 | Whole $12.99

Hot Subs and Specialties

  • Pizza Sub: $7.99 (Mini) | $10.99 (Whole)
  • Steak or Chicken Finger Sub: $9.99 (Mini) | $12.99 (Whole)
  • The Stinger Sub: The sandwich version of the pizza. $11.99 (Mini) | $14.99 (Whole)
  • Royal Sub: Sausage and Capicola. $9.99 (Mini) | $12.99 (Whole)

Tacos

Served on soft tortilla shells with lettuce, tomato, and cheese.

  • Beef & Cheese: $5.99
  • Steak Taco: $6.99
  • Chicken Finger Taco: $7.99

Appetizers and Sides

If you are looking for something unique, the Funnel Cake Fries are a must-try. They offer a carnival-like dessert experience in a fry format.

  • Funnel Cake Fries: 10 for $3.99 | 30 for $7.99
  • Mozzarella Sticks: $6.99 (Small) | $10.99 (Large)
  • Sampler Platter: Includes 2 chicken fingers, 2 mozzarella sticks, 4 poppers, 2 pizza logs, and onion rings for $14.99.
  • Pizza Logs: A local favorite—deep-fried egg roll wrappers filled with cheese and pepperoni. $6.99.

How to Save Money: Daily Specials and Combos

The Pizza Heist is known for its aggressive daily pricing. Planning your order around these days can save you significant money.

  • Monday Special: A Large Cheese + 1 Topping Pizza for only $13.00. This is widely considered the best value of the week.
  • Tuesday Special: 3 Beef & Cheese Tacos for the price of 2 (approx. $11.98).
  • Wednesday Special: Take $1.00 off any whole 12" sub.
  • Friday Special: Purchase any large pizza combo (like the Pizza & 20 Wings for $38.99) and receive a Free 2-liter soda.

Everyday Combo Specials

  • Small Pizza for Two: Small Cheese + 1 Topping with 10 wings for $21.99.
  • Family Value Special: Large Cheese + 1 Topping with 20 wings and a free soda for $38.99.
  • The Sheet Heist: One sheet pizza (Cheese + 1 Topping) and 50 wings for $82.99.

FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions About The Pizza Heist

What is the most popular item at The Pizza Heist?

The Stinger Pizza and Stinger Sub are the most famous items. They combine steak and chicken fingers, representing the best of Buffalo-style comfort food.

Where is The Pizza Heist located?

The main location is at 231 Aurora Street, Lancaster, NY 14086.

Does The Pizza Heist offer gluten-free options?

Yes, they offer a Cauliflower Crust for their pizzas for an additional charge of $3.00, allowing those with gluten sensitivities to enjoy their specialty toppings.

What are the operating hours?

They are generally open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM from Sunday to Thursday, and they stay open later until 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Can I order online?

Yes, The Pizza Heist has an integrated online ordering system through their official website and major delivery platforms, making it easy to customize your "heist."

Summary of The Pizza Heist Menu

The Pizza Heist in Lancaster, NY, stands out by offering more than just standard pizza. Their commitment to local favorites like the Stinger Pizza, the use of high-quality Costanzo's rolls for subs, and unique desserts like funnel cake fries make them a staple in the community. With daily specials like the $13.00 Monday Large Pizza, it remains one of the most cost-effective ways to feed a family or a group of friends in the Lancaster area. Whether you are a fan of traditional thin-crust pizza or looking for a meat-loaded "Carnivore" sheet, their menu is designed to satisfy high-volume cravings with high-quality ingredients.